Baker Mayfield is in many ways the perfect college football player: Good enough to play at an elite level, but because he is not an ideal NFL prospect, he stuck around long enough to lead Oklahoma to three Big 12 championships and two playoff appearances.
Mayfield won the Heisman Trophy on Saturday night and become the first senior to take home the award since Ohio State’s Troy Smith in 2006. Mayfield has at least one more game to impress NFL scouts. Maybe two. The second-ranked Sooners play Georgia in the College Football Playoff at the Rose Bowl on Jan. 1.
Then it will be time for the former walk-on to once again prove some folks wrong. Listed at 6-foot-1, 220 pounds – and that might be a stretch – Mayfield is not the prototype NFL quarterback prospect, but that hasn’t stopped him from becoming one of the most prolific passers in college football history.
“I’m going to have the same work ethic and mentality,” Mayfield said. “I think I’ve proven that size doesn’t matter. Even if you had a 6-5 quarterback, you’re not going to see over my left tackle. He’s 6-8. I’m just excited to be able to play the game of football. Winning is fun, and something that I work hard to do. That should be accounted for more than any size, any measurement.”
Mayfield’s CFL rights are currently owned by the Toronto Argonauts, who acquired them in a 2016 deal with the Saskatchewan Roughriders.
He’s likely to be a much-debated prospect in the months leading up to the NFL draft in late April. Same goes for 2017 Heisman finalist, and last year’s Heisman winner, Lamar Jackson of Louisville, who is currently on the B.C. Lions negotiation list.
Mayfield will likely be compared to other undersized quarterbacks like Drew Brees, Russell Wilson and maybe Johnny Manziel, his CFL rights reside on the Ticats neg list. His mobility and ability to improvise makes those Wilson-Manziel comparisons seem more apt.
“Being compared to those guys is an honour,” Mayfield said.
The Manziel comparison is not necessarily positive. Manziel was a college superstar and Heisman winner who played a highly improvisational game. He was a much better and more frequent runner in college than Mayfield. Mayfield is a more refined passer. Manziel’s biggest issues, though, were not physical skills and talent. He came into the NFL with baggage when he was a first-round pick by the Cleveland Browns in 2014. After two years in the league, he was released, with some questioning his commitment to football. Manziel has had run-ins with the law in college and after.
Mayfield was arrested in February and pleaded guilty to three misdemeanours, including public intoxication. He was also punished by Sooners coach Lincoln Riley after making an obscene gesture toward Kansas players during a game in November.
“We’re going to hear plenty of Johnny Manziel comparisons because they’re convenient. And I think a big reason is many overlooked Manziel’s issues and got burned, so they’ll overcompensate with Mayfield even though his red flags aren’t at a Manziel level,” said draft analyst Dane Brugler of NFL Draft Scout.com. “I’m not saying there aren’t concerns _ there are. Mayfield needs to mature. But Manziel felt entitled, Mayfield feels motivated, which is a key difference when assessing each’s character.”
Trent Dilfer, the former NFL quarterback who trains personal quarterback coaches and works with the Elite 11 camp for top high school prospects, said he doesn’t necessarily like the Wilson comparisons for Mayfield.
“Baker is a fantastic quarterback. I have nothing bad to say about Baker except that he doesn’t have a lot of power,” Dilfer said.
The quarterbacks that most get talked about as possible first-rounders this year are UCLA’s Josh Rosen and USC’s Sam Darnold – two third-year players who could leave college early. Wyoming’s Josh Allen, another junior, has the size (6-5, 240 pounds) and physical tools that NFL teams love but is raw.
“These guys are big, thick-jointed, powerful guys,” Dilfer said. “They have NFL bodies.”
Mayfield doesn’t have that, but he has completed more than 70 per cent of his passes the last two seasons and accuracy is maybe the most important trait for a quarterback transitioning from college to the NFL.
Brugler said Mayfield generates a wide range of evaluations among NFL scouts.
“You can count on one hand the number of NFL starters his size, and his brash personality won’t be for everyone, so his skill set requires a GM willing to think outside the box. But he routinely backed it up on the field at Oklahoma,” Brugler said. “All of these prospects have flaws, so Mayfield is right in the mix to be a first-round pick.”