Ticats blow early lead in pre-season loss to Argos

Toronto quarterback Dakota Prukop hit Jamel Johnson for a 28-yard touchdown late in the fourth as the Argonauts climbed out of a 16-0 deficit to defeat the Hamilton Tiger-Cats 23-16 at Tim Hortons Field in CFL pre-season action Friday night.

Prukop, fighting for a spot on the practice roster, was the third Toronto pivot to see action and led the 97-yard game-winning scoring drive, taking the lead for the first time with 3:02 left in the game.

James Wilder and Jimmy Ralph also scored touchdowns for Toronto while Brian Tyms and Ross Scheuerman scored for Hamilton.

Toronto kickers Lirim Hajrullahu and Ronnie Pfeffer both saw playing time. Hajrullahu kicked a convert. Pfeffer missed both field-goal attempts, from 38 and 48 yards. He added a 68-yard punt single and a convert. Hamilton kicker Sergio Castillo kicked two converts.

Pfeffer’s punt single made it 16-15 just 19 seconds into the fourth and Prukop came in at quarterback for the Argos. Pfeffer’s missed 48-yarder tied the game at 16 with 9:39 left to play.

Hamilton used four quarterbacks during the game: Zach Collaros, Jeremiah Masoli, Cody Keith, and Logan Kilgore. Toronto started McLeod Bethel-Thompson, followed by Jeff Mathews and Prukop.

Collaros started the game for Hamilton and left early in the second quarter right after throwing the game’s first touchdown, a six-yarder to Tyms. He finished with 10 completions on 17 attempts for 126 yards and one TD.

Collaros’ health will be a storyline this year. He has missed time due to concussions and this time last year was still out of the line-up recovering from a knee injury suffered in 2015. He didn’t return until Week 8.

Hamilton back up, Masoli, took over in the second and took advantage of Toronto receiver Joe Morgan’s fumble on his own 40, immediately leading a scoring drive that ended with Scheuerman’s two-yard plunge to give the Ticats a 16-0 lead.

A conceded safety by Toronto’s Hajrullahu midway through the first quarter was set up by Ticat Adrian Tracy’s sack of Bethel-Thompson at the Toronto two-yard line and put Hamilton on the board first.

Bethel-Thompson started at pivot for Toronto. The 28-year-old out of Sacramento State is also battling for a spot on the practice roster. He finished the first quarter with zero completions on five attempts and the Argo offence only generated nine yards.

He made his first pass completion on his first play of the second, and the ball was promptly fumbled by Morgan, setting up a Ticat score. But late in the second he engineered a 39-yard scoring drive that ended with a one-yard TD run by Wilder to get to the half down 16-7. He finished with five completions on 13 attempts for 78 yards.

Ricky Ray, who has only started 12 games in the past two years due to an assortment of injuries, is expected to start the season for Toronto with Drew Willy expected to be his backup.

Mathews started the third for Toronto. Late in the quarter he led a 75-yard scoring drive, ending with a 22-yard TD pass to Ralph. The two-point convert attempt failed but the Argos pulled to 16-14. That would be it for Mathews, who went 12 for 15, 136 yards and one TD.

Masoli finished the night completing five-of-six pass attempts for 48 yards and one interception, plus a 16-yard rush. He was replaced by Keith with under three minutes left in the third. Keith was pulled late in the fourth having completed one-of-four pass attempts for 11 yards and was replaced by Kilgore, who finished completing two-of-six for 68 yards.

– CP


11 Comments on Ticats blow early lead in pre-season loss to Argos

  1. I thought that’s Mathews looked great.

    • So did I – maybe he needed a change of scenery but if he was kept would have been our 3rd stringer for sure.

    • Mark. Agree. Not questioning the move. But I liked both Mathews and LeFevour and I would like to see them do well. Masoli would still be my first choice as backup.

      • Mathews looked better than Cody Keith or Logan Kilgore but of course of Golson was not hurt, the conversation might not matter. Mathews would still be 3rd string not 2nd string.

    • Will be extremely disappointed if Cody Fajardo is not one of the top 3. If they cut Fajardo or move him to #4 will be disappointed.

  2. Not trying to start anything here… but after sitting in the stands on a gorgeous summer evening and closely watching the game last night I have a few observations…

    1.) Collaros and our starting offence were just a little bit above putrid in their 1st quarter performance… it’s pretty obvious we don’t have a running game because we can’t run the ball…

    2.) Ross Schuerman is a better RB than Gable…

    3.) If Ricky Ray had started Ticats surely would have fallen behind by two TDs… which seems to be the standard for Austin ‘s team…

    4.) Masoli looked better than Collaros at QB… made some nice runs for 1st down… extended plays with his mobility, threw some nice passes and looked tougher…

    5.) The kicking game looked better in the 1st half… not so impressed with the newest guy in the 2nd… sorry both names escape me right now…

    6.) Toronto has a new kick returner that looked dangerous every time he touched the ball…

    Not trying to start anything… I get it that it’s still preseason but from what I saw looks like we will have yet another slow start to season… maybe 1-4…

    Just saying…

    • Philski // June 17, 2017 at 1:41 pm //

      Whether it’s pre-season or not it sucks to lose – especially against Toronto. A winning culture is cultivated right from the get go (see Lions) and I just don’t see it with this team. You could have sworn you were watching a game from last year and observed the same troublesome things: no running game, stupid penalties, dropped passes, inability to hold a lead – emphasized by the D folding down the stretch and surrendering the winning points. So your 1-4 prognosis is not completely off base as well as another season of mediocrity.

  3. S McBride (TFMCB ) // June 17, 2017 at 9:16 am //

    Yes Matthews did look good but I think he’s better suited to a Trestman type offense because he’s more of a pocket passer. In spite of his familiarity with Austin’s offense from Cornell, he couldn’t seem to manage it consistently well at the pro level. By comparison, Keith’s inexperience really showed up last night. I thought he looked better in Ottawa.

  4. Snake – Masoli may have looked sharper than Collaros because he actually played about a half of football last week while this was Zach’s first bout on the field. I thought that he looked fine once he got going. It didn’t help that Tyms dropped a couple of passes that could have been caught. See my previous comment about Ray not playing. 🙂
    I agree with you that Castillo (1st half) looked better than Fera (2nd half) and probably has nailed the job. Scheuerman may not have been facing the same defensive front as CJ or maybe the blocking for him was better. He’s impressive for sure but I wouldn’t say he’s better than Gable. Just a few thoughts from what I saw watching online.

  5. Jimbobray // June 17, 2017 at 11:42 am //

    Prukop will likely be Argos starting qb before the year is out if Ricky Ray goes down with injury. Willy, no hope, Matthews, possibly for a while, Bethel-Thompson, no hope, Fejaro, possible but not a real drop back QB.

  6. Fajardo was the best qb last week for Argos, never had a chance to play game 2, so will be very disappointed if Cody is moved

Comments are closed.